by rainshadow Sat Aug 19, 2017 10:45 am
I'm in complete agreement. Had I never read the series, I would have loved a good deal of the show. There were a small handful of episodes that as a book reader made me actually appreciate the episode themselves, but overall most of the content of the show was a blatant disregard for the books. Characters being poorly cast when compared to their book counterparts. Huge details that were omitted or blatantly changed. I will never forgive that Rachel was essentially tossed aside after her single episode with no hope of being brought back in a semblance of the character she became in the books. She might have been my favorite character in the entire series (hell, even Goodkind disappointed me with how little she was eventually used when I was under the impression that she would grow to be a major character by the end of the series -- honestly I hope she eventually gets her own series and becomes the next woman Seeker... LOL).
Otherwise it was pretty well made for a TV show of its type. The fact that it was tied to Sword of Truth was a killer.
What should be a major rule in film/TV show development that is completely ignored way too often: When you have a show that has a built-in fanbase, you don't ostracize your fanbase. In doing so you lose that portion of viewership automatically. You're probably already going to get the fanbase that came after (The Save Our Seeker campaign was comprised primarily by people who hadn't read the books). Don't kill yourself before you even begin by removing the original fanbase from the equation.